"The left needs two things to survive. It needs mediocrity, and it needs dependence. It nurtures mediocrity in the public schools and the universities. It nurtures dependence through its empire of government programs. A nation that embraces mediocrity and dependence betrays itself, and can only fade away, wondering all the time what might have been."
- Urgent Agenda
Please see note about expiring subscriptions here.
DIGGING THAT HOLE DEEPER - AT 7:18 P.M. ET: Does Caroline Kennedy understand what politics is about? The question is being asked as she seems to be sinking in her bid to be appointed to succeed Hillary Clinton in the Senate. Now she's snapping at reporters, as this quote from a piece in London's Telegraph notes:
At one point Miss Kennedy, being asked to describe the moment she decided she wanted the Senate seat, asked the reporters: "Have you guys ever thought about writing for, like, a woman's magazine or something?" One of them responded: "What do you have against women's magazines?" Miss Kennedy shot back: "Nothing at all, but I thought you were the crack political team here."
Another reporter asked "Would you have sought this if there hadn't been an appointment open, if it had been an election?", Miss Kennedy said: "I think we covered that." The reporter pressed: "What's the answer, then, if we covered it?"
Geez.
OUTRAGEOUS CNN HEADLINE - AT 6:53 P.M. ET: This headline appears at the CNN website: World rallies around Palestinians amid Gaza offensive
COMMENT: Unfortunately, this is all too typical of leftist CNN. There is nothing to justify the headline. There are some demonstrations by Muslims and their allies in some countries, but that's about it. I monitored CNN today and found the same bias - an almost obsessive attention to small demonstrations, as if they represent "the world." The world, of course, doesn't do anything.
LETTER TO LEDEEN
Posted at 1:59 p.m. ET
The distinguished foreign-policy analyst, Michael Ledeen, maintains a close connection to the American military. We quoted from his son, Gabe, a Marine officer, just recently.
Mr. Ledeen has received a sterling letter from a soldier in Afghanistan. I want to share it with you because it reflects the moral considerations of an obviously thoughtful man:
I’ve spent a considerable amount of time in the last ten months, contemplating the necessity of my being here. Some days it feels as though nothing we do will make a difference. That this country is doomed to remain in poverty and violence and there is nothing anyone can do to change its irrevocable course. That no amount of American blood or treasure will ever deter or change the minds of those who have decided that America is a great evil, enforcing its will upon the world. That America is the cause of their hatred. That we Soldiers were sent to fight on ‘bad intelligence’ or for the wrong reasons. That we are in Afghanistan for vengeance and Iraq for oil. That if we just left, these countries would return to a blissful peace, free from American oppression. And through many nights, in a pitch black that is only possible hundreds of miles from electricity, I have questioned the mission. I have questioned if Afghanistan is worth it. I have questioned whether or not my being here has made a difference.
Today I received my answer. Today a suicide bomber drove his truck into a crowd of children at a checkpoint. At last count, over 20 children were killed instantly when his car detonated. As of 30 minutes ago frantic mothers and fathers were still calling the American base to see if their child was at our hospital. We could only say ‘no, no children were brought to the hospital. None of the children’s bodies were recovered, none survived the blast.’…In Saving Private Ryan, Tom Hanks reflects on the Soldiers he’s lost. Comparing each one lost under his command to a dozen saved by his command. Today dozens of young, innocent, unspoiled lives were lost. There is no other way to describe it other than a massacre.
In the last ten months we have stopped seventeen suicide bombers. Either killed or captured before they could reach their targets. These suicide bombers have come from Pakistan, Uzbekistan, Turkey, Dubai, Chechnya and Germany. These were terrorists that were going to find a target. Somewhere. They chose Afghanistan...I can’t estimate how many children have been saved by us being here, but I can say without a doubt that it is at least one. And in that I have my answer. I am a Father and a Husband. I am a Son and I am a Brother. I know I am loved and I know the sadness it would bring if I were lost. But I am also a Soldier. I have sworn to protect those who cannot protect themselves and I will uphold this oath. Today it was the children in Khost Province, Afghanistan. Last week, Mumbai. Five years ago, London. Seven years ago, New York, Arlington and Pennsylvania. My answers are simple: we do make a difference, blood and treasure has been well spent, the darkest shadows of America can’t compare to the evil that lurks in this world, this is not a war of vengeance, this is a war of good and evil, their hatred is bred and taught, America is not the cause and terror will follow us no matter where we are.
Wonderful, wonderful.
Michael Ledeen adds:
All those killers in Afghanistan, the ones who murdered the schoolchildren, were fighting to create–or recreate–a society in which everyone is dominated by a harsh code of behavior, justified by the divinely decreed necessity of restraining man’s sinful inclinations. That society was, and if they win will be, a brutal tyranny. That it is justified in the name of Islam does not impress me any more than when it was justified by an appeal to race, or Marx, or Hutu supremacy. It is the same old war, and I remain convinced that this concept should underlie American policy in the world. We are obliged to combat tyrants, like it or not. For they will always feel obliged to attack us.
My friend the Soldier in Afghanistan figured it all out in a nanosecond. Let’s hope our leaders finally get it.
Just as important, let's hope our journalists finally get it.
MORE CHANGE WE CAN'T BELIEVE IN - AT 9:42 A.M. ET: USA Today reports that Adolphus Towns, the incoming chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform, the top oversight committee in Congress, attended only 12 of the committee's 74 meetings in the last two-year session.
COMMENT: This is disgraceful. How about reforming the reform committee?
THE HILLARY DOLLAR - AT 9:32 A.M. ET: From The New York Post: SOME of those who are owed $6.3 million by Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign are annoyed at the senator's grandstanding. Clinton received a $2,300 contribution from Caroline Kennedy, but returned it after Kennedy very publicly endorsed Barack Obama. "I don't see anything wrong with Caroline Kennedy's money," said one source. "Returning it was just an act of spite."
COMMENT: How juicy! Spite. Revenge. Knifings. Look, maybe Hillary can arrange a bailout. I mean, $6.3-million. That's loose change.
BEST QUOTE OF THE DAY, THUS FAR - AT 7:51 A.M. ET: From Bill Kristol, in The New York Times:
Bah, humbug. Those of us who dislike finger-wagging nanny-state-nagging liberalism relish the prospect of President Barack Obama sneaking a cigarette on the second floor of the White House while rereading Harry V. Jaffa’s great work on Lincoln, “Crisis of the House Divided,” then taking a break to stroll over to take a look at the White House’s copy of Emanuel Leutze’s painting “Washington Crossing the Delaware,” then going back to the family quarters to tell his kids to get back to memorizing some patriotic poetry, all of this interrupted occasionally by calls from Gen. David Petraeus and Gen. Ray Odierno — his Ulysses Grant and William Tecumseh Sherman — to discuss progress in the wars we’re fighting, or from Rick Warren to discuss their joint efforts to fight AIDS in Africa and to reduce the number of abortions in the U.S.
Now that’s a presidency I can believe in.
Leave us hope.
GAZA UPDATE - AT 7:34 A.M. ET: From The Jerusalem Post: Hizbullah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah attacked Arab nations - particularly Egypt and Jordan - in a televised speech Sunday and accused them of cooperation with Israel in its offensive in the Gaza Strip. "There are some who speak of Arab silence, but this is wrong. There is full Arab cooperation, especially by those who have signed so-called peace agreements with Israel," Nasrallah said.
COMMENT: The splits in the Arab world, among the dear, brotherly, leaders, are becoming clearer.
NEXT COMMENT: There are the usual charges that Israel is using "disproportionate" force. I'm baffled by such remarks. The one thing you don't want in war is a fair fight. It isn't a game. Imagine if, after Pearl Harbor, the United States had simply sought to bomb a Japanese naval base, and left it at that? You know, proportional force. The proper force is the amount needed to win, quickly and decisively.
HANSON PREDICTS
Posted at 7:22 a.m. ET
We're not much for predictions around here, but Victor Davis Hanson has written a witty column about what to expect next July, once The One has been in power for a time. Ah, the progress. Ah, the goodness. Ah, the purification of our moral soul:
By July, we will come to feel that 2009 will be one of the most upbeat years in our history, as what used to be the news media begins to get behind America and report on all the mysteriously wonderful things that are suddenly taking place.
We celebrate. We give thanks.
All the campaign talk of the Great Depression, a Vietnam-like war, and our shredded Constitution will now thankfully subside as the Obama administration assumes office and solves problems with conciliation, dialogue, and multilateral wisdom, rather than shrillness, unilateralism, preemption, and my-way-or-the-highway dogmatism.
What a guy, this Barack. Does it all in six months.
Indeed, almost supernaturally crises will be solved with the departure of the hated Bush: no more flooding streets from cracked water mains that were a result of a President's neglect of infrastructure, and no more spontaneous crashes of Mississippi River bridges due to diversions of critical federal aid from cash-strapped states to Iraq. And when the temperatures rise or drop, the wind howls, the clouds burst forth or go away, the snow melts or piles up, it will be, well, nature that caused the havoc, not the current occupant of the White House who failed to sign Kyoto.
See, we told you. It was all BUSH. Anderson Cooper says so.
Some military action abroad could be necessary--and necessarily reported on as measured and reluctant, rather than cowboyish and gratuitous. European whining will be a result of miscommunications or the Euros' unfair caricatures of Americans, not Bush's alienation of allies...
...If an administration official quits, goes on 60 Minutes, and writes a nasty tell-all book about Obama's insensitivity and his government's directionless ennui, he will be a heretic, a whiner, a turncoat, not a truth teller or brave maverick who blew the whistle in need of a bestseller hyped from NPR to the New York Times.
What a world this will be. I can't wait for perfection. I want to take notes.
So all that will change for now will be the sudden absence of shrill complaints that we live in an America without a Constitution. Static, same-old, same-old government policy will, of course, be said to have altered radically ("hoped and changed"), but it will also be refashioned in the media as "sober" and "judicious", as the administration moves "in circumspect fashion" to probe and explore "complex" and often "paradoxical" matters of national security that "indeed at the end of the day have no easy answers."
We have to remember, in July, to check back and see how much of Hanson's column comes true. I'll bet it will be a great deal.
"Diversity" and "progressive" themes will replace Bush's hokey old-time patriotism, as we return to a more nuanced and sophisticated love of country that at last "came home."
To Harvard, to Yale, to Georgetown.
Jimmy Carter will once again be weird old jet-setting Jimmy Carter, a meddler, a spoiler, a PR junkie on the verge of senility rather than the principled Nobel laureate of the Carter Center.
Let us hope for that one.
Those inside the big house change, the commandments on the barn wall subtly are crossed out and updated, but the farm for us animals stays about the same.
I personally find this story very distressing. One of the things some reporters noticed during the campaign was that Barack Obama did not do well under pressure. He seemed to get testy, even rude. You think about that when you realize the kind of crises he may have to face.
The problem has resurfaced. I get the feeling that some in the press, no matter how in the tank their organizations may be for Obama, are not pleased by what they see. The Politico reports:
HONOLULU – The media glare, the constant security appendage and the sheer production that has become a morning jog or a hankering for an ice cream cone – it’s been closing in on Barack Obama for some time...
...Obama even took the unusual step Friday morning of leaving behind the pool of reporters assigned to follow him, taking his daughters to a nearby water park without them. It was a breach of longstanding protocol between presidents (or presidents-elect) and the media, that a gaggle of reporters representing television, print and wire services is with his motorcade at all times.
Not exactly a good start for a "transparent" presidency.
After ordering a tuna melt on 12-grain bread, Obama approached reporters and placed his hand on the shoulder of pool reporter Philip Rucker of The Washington Post, who was scribbling away in his notebook.
“You don't really need to write all that down,” Obama said.
Whoops. The reporter determines that, Mr. President-elect, not the person being covered.
All presidents and would-be presidents struggle with “the bubble” – the security detail and the always-there reporters that impose barriers to any spontaneous interaction with the outside world.
But Obama seems to be struggling particularly hard, particularly early.
Wait 'til he has to deal with the Arabs and Israelis.
Four years ago Obama was an Illinois state senator who was on his way to the U.S. Senate. Next month, he will become one of only a handful of modern presidents who has not endured a similar bubble as a governor or top U.S. official before taking office.
Hmm. The experience thing. Not relevant, not relevant.
And even though the pool photographers remained out of sight and without an image of these private moments, Obama seems to be tiring of the journalists who have followed him daily since the campaign.
“OK, guys, come on," Obama said last Sunday, looking toward photographers clicking away as he warmed up before a round of golf. “How many shots do you need?”
It’s been a progression. And Obama’s frustration shows in waves.
How long do you think it will be before he blows up at a press conference? On live TV?
Look, we can all sympathize with a young guy who has young kids, and wants some privacy. That's fine. But a low frustration tolerance isn't very healthy in a president. He will have to make life-and-death decisions, and may have to do so in the glare of publicity.
Eisenhower had a famous temper, but he kept it private. Bill Clinton was known to go over the top, but generally in private. If a president shows stress and anger in public, he starts to lose the aura that surrounds the office. He can even begin to look weak.
We've given considerable attention to the Caroline Kennedy saga in New York. It's important for many reasons. First, the successor to Hillary Clinton in the Senate is important by definition. Second, if appointed to Clinton's seat in the Senate by the governor, Kennedy will be the subject of instant presidential talk for 2016. Third, having endorsed Obama and helped defeat Clinton in the presidential primaries, Kennedy's appointment would be a direct insult to Clinton, just as Hillary is becoming secretary of state.
But the Caroline boomlet is running into stiff winds. There is resentment. There is talk of dynasty. There is ridicule. Michael Goodwin of the Daily News has written the most stunning rebuke of the once first daughter. This is very strong stuff, especially in liberal New York. His piece is called "Say goodnight, Caroline: How JFK's daughter flubbed the audition to become the next Senator Kennedy." Pretty much says it, doesn't it? Read on:
...a strange thing is happening on the way to the coronation. The wheels of the bandwagon are coming off. Fantasy is giving way to inescapable truth.
That truth is that Kennedy is not ready for the job and doesn't deserve it. Somebody who loves her should tell her.
Her quest is becoming a cringe-inducing experience, as painful to watch as it must be to endure. Because she is the only survivor of that dreamy time nearly 50 years ago, she remains an iconic figure. But in the last few days, her mini-campaign has proved she has little to offer New Yorkers except her name.
Yikes. That is heresy. People have been burned at the stake in New York for less than that.
Camelot must be Gaelic for chutzpah. New York can do better.
And...
...the minute she faced the routine questions that help define a candidate for virtually any office, she had nothing to say. There was no "there" there.
It gets worse:
"As a mother, as an author, as an education advocate and from a family that really has spent generations in public service, I feel this commitment," she said. "This is a time when nobody can afford to sit it out, and I feel I have something to offer."
The "sit it out" part is revealing. Among those who want the job, she has done the least public service by any measure. She didn't even vote in about half the contested elections in the last 20 years.
Finally...
Limousine liberals are a dime a dozen, and carpetbaggers are nothing new in New York. And with the social scene constantly churning out the old for the next new thing, there's no reason middle-aged dilettantes can't also try their hand at politics.
They just can't start in the Senate.
That, from Goodwin, is a public knifing. It is also a rebuke to President-elect Obama, who certainly had to approve this foray into politics by Caroline Kennedy, who headed his vice-presidential search team.
The Israeli operation in Gaza becomes more intriguing. It no longer looks like a one-dimensional retaliation for Hamas rocket fire. It looks like an attempt to bring down the Hamas government in Gaza - which seized control of the Gaza Strip by force - and replace it with the more moderate Palestinian Authority.
Despite the pro forma statements from Arab capitals, and their amen corner in the world's leftist precincts, other Arab statements are remarkable for what they say and don't say. The Jerusalem Post reports:
Hamas could have prevented the "massacre" in the Gaza Strip, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas said Sunday in Cairo.
"We spoke to them and told them 'Please, we ask you not to end the cease-fire. Let it continue,'" Abbas said during a joint press conference with Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit. "We want to protect the Gaza Strip. We don't want it to be destroyed."
Abbas called on Hamas to renew the cease-fire with Israel to avoid further bloodshed in Gaza.
Hmm. Not exactly a ringing endorsement of the "dear Palestinian brothers."
And the foreign minister of Egypt, the most important Arab country, weighed in:
Aboul Gheit also attacked Hamas, saying the group had prevented people wounded in the Israeli offensive from passing into Egypt to receive medical attention.
"We are waiting for the wounded Palestinians to reach Egypt. They aren't being allowed to go through," he said.
Asked who was to blame for the dire situation in Gaza, the foreign minister replied: "Ask the party that controls Gaza."
No one is suggesting that these two worthies have become instant Zionists. But their statements are stunning. Clearly, neither has much use for Hamas.
This is speculation, but I wonder whether this whole Israeli operation is being coordinated with Washington, and even with the Obama people. If Obama comes in and Hamas is driven from Gaza, his job in Middle East negotiations becomes that much easier.
We'll see. This could be a decisive moment, unless the rug is pulled out from beneath Israel by the usual forces of "realism" - read that "defeat" - in Western foreign ministries.
"What you see is news. What you know is background. What you feel is opinion."
- Lester Markel, late Sunday editor
of The New York Times.
THE ANGEL'S CORNER*
Part I of a two-part edition of The Angel's Corner was sent Wednesday. Part II was sent Friday and features a remembrance of Marilyn Monroe.
* Previously called Subscriber Services. Angels are, of course, people who invest in Broadway shows and make them possible - kind of like our subscribers making Urgent Agenda possible.
TO SUBSCRIBERS:
The first six-month subscriptions to Urgent Agenda, entered in late June and early July, are about to expire. You'll be alerted. We do hope you'll renew, and even consider renewing for a year. We are having a great time at The Angel's Corner. We'll have a better time in 2009.
SUBSCRIPTIONS
Subscriptions to URGENT AGENDA are voluntary. Why subscribe to something you're getting free? To help guarantee that you'll continue to get it at all, and to get the additional features we now offer subscribers.
Subscriptions sustain us. Payments are through PayPal and are secure, but you do not have to sign up for a PayPal account. Credit cards are fine.
FOR A ONE-YEAR ($48) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK:
FOR A SIX-MONTH ($26) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK:
IF YOU DON'T WISH A SET SUBSCRIPTION, BUT PREFER TO DONATE ANY OTHER AMOUNT TO SUSTAIN URGENT AGENDA, CLICK:
THE CURRENT QUESTION
This space will regularly raise questions that relate to the news, but transcend daily headlines. The idea is to stimulate talk about basic issues. Our last question asked:
Last week we asked:
What is the most important New Year's resolution that Barack Obama should make?
Give three examples of change in American life, culture, or politics that you could actually believe in.
If you'd like to send us your thoughts, click: response@urgentagenda.com (Please stay within two or three paragraphs. We try to print every reply, if space allows. Place your name at the end of the message if you wish your name published. This question will stay up through Sunday.)
SEARCH URGENT AGENDA
POWER LINE
It's a privilege for me to post periodic pieces at Power Line. To go to Power Line, click here.